Walk down any grooming aisle and you will find pomades, clays, waxes, pastes, fibers and creams, all promising hold. The good news is that the choice really comes down to one question: do you want your hair shiny and smooth, or matte and textured?
Pomade is for shine and slick, combed styles. Clay is for matte texture and volume. Wax, and its close cousin fiber, gives a pliable, piece-y finish you can rework through the day. Below are two picks for each, every one checked live on Amazon, plus how to choose and how to wash each one out.
Shine and slick styles: a water-based pomade like Suavecito Original Hold, around $15. Matte texture and volume: a clay like Baxter of California Clay Pomade, around $20. Messy, separated texture you can rework: a wax like TIGI Bed Head Matte Separation Workable Wax, around $16. Thin hair usually looks fuller with clay than with pomade.
Pomade vs. Clay vs. Wax at a Glance
| Type | Finish | Hold | Best For | Our Pick | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water-based pomade | Medium to high shine | Medium to strong | Side parts, slick backs, pompadours | Suavecito Original Hold, ~$15 | Check Price → |
| Oil-based pomade | High shine | Medium to strong, restylable | Vintage, greased looks | Skip unless you want that look | |
| Clay | Matte | Strong to very high | Textured crops, quiffs, volume | Baxter Clay Pomade, ~$20 | Check Price → |
| Wax or fiber | Matte to low shine | Strong, pliable | Short, spiky or separated texture | TIGI Matte Separation Wax, ~$16 | Check Price → |
Hold and finish from each brand's product listing. Oil-based vs. water-based details from Reuzel's pomade guide. Prices from Amazon on October 31, 2026.
Pomade: For Shine and Slick Styles
Pomade is the classic. It gives a smooth, combed finish with shine, which is what you want for a side part, a slick back or a pompadour. The big decision is water-based or oil-based.
Water-based pomades are what most people should buy. According to Reuzel, they rinse out with water and dry to hold a style all day. Oil-based pomades have a waxier feel and higher shine, and stay soft so you can restyle through the day, but they do not rinse out. Reuzel says ingredients like beeswax repel water, so you need a degreasing routine to get them out. Unless you specifically want that greased, vintage look, start with water-based.
Suavecito Pomade, Original Hold
A medium hold, medium shine water-based pomade that washes out with just water. Apply to damp hair for more shine, dry hair for less.
Layrite Original Pomade, 4.25 oz
A water-soluble, medium hold, medium shine pomade that feels smooth rather than waxy or sticky. The step up from Suavecito, around $24.
Suavecito is the one to try first: it has more than 28,000 ratings, and the retailer's listing notes it washes out with just water and gives more shine on damp hair, less on dry. Layrite Original is the step up, a water-soluble, medium hold, medium shine pomade that Layrite describes as smooth rather than waxy or sticky.
Clay: For Matte Texture and Volume
Clay is the opposite of pomade. It dries matte, with no shine, and it is built for texture and volume: textured crops, messy quiffs and anything that should look styled without looking wet. It is also the better choice for fine or thinning hair, because a matte finish makes hair look fuller where shine tends to clump it together.
Baxter of California Clay Pomade
A strong, long-lasting hold with a matte finish that separates, defines and molds. Around $20 for 2 oz.
Hanz de Fuko Claymation
Super high hold with a shine-free matte finish, in a clay and wax hybrid that stays pliable so you can reshape it. Around $28.
Baxter is the classic clay pomade, rated by the brand as a strong, long-lasting hold with a matte finish. Hanz de Fuko Claymation is the pick if you need maximum hold: the brand rates it super high hold, and its clay and wax blend stays pliable, so you can push hair back into place mid-day. On a budget, the Cremo Hair Clay Pomade gives a high hold, matte finish for around $10 with more than 5,000 ratings.
Wax and Fiber: For Separated, Reworkable Texture
Waxes and fibers sit between pomade and clay. The finish is mostly matte or low shine, the hold is strong but stays pliable, and they are best for short hair where you want visible, separated pieces: spiky, textured or deliberately messy.
TIGI Bed Head for Men Matte Separation Workable Wax
A workable wax with matte definition and hold that TIGI says is strong enough to resist humidity. Rated 5 out of 5 for texture and hold.
American Crew Fiber, 3 oz
A high hold, low shine fiber with a pliable, matte finish, recommended for hair 1 to 3 inches long. Nearly 15,000 ratings.
TIGI's Matte Separation Workable Wax is the one to buy if humidity flattens your style; TIGI rates it 5 out of 5 for hold and texture. American Crew Fiber is technically a fiber rather than a wax, but it behaves like a stiff, pliable wax, and American Crew recommends it for hair 1 to 3 inches long, which makes it ideal for short textured cuts.
How to Pick in Ten Seconds
- Combed, smooth, shiny style? Water-based pomade.
- Textured, messy or voluminous style? Clay.
- Short hair with spiky or separated pieces? Wax or fiber.
- Fine or thinning hair? Clay, used sparingly.
- Need it to rinse out easily? Avoid oil-based pomade.
How Much to Use, and How to Apply It
Start with a fingertip-sized amount, less than you think. Rub it between your palms until it warms and disappears into your skin, then work it through from the back of your head forward so the front does not get the biggest glob. Pomade goes on damp or dry hair depending on how much shine you want; clays and waxes work best on dry or towel-dried hair. You can always add more, but too much product weighs hair down and looks greasy.
How to Wash Each One Out
Water-based pomades rinse out with water and a normal shampoo. Most clays and waxes come out with a regular shampoo; if you used a lot, shampoo twice. Oil-based pomade is the hard one: Reuzel's method is to work conditioner into dry hair first, leave it for 2 to 3 minutes to loosen the grease, then lather shampoo on top before rinsing with warm water and finishing with a regular shampoo. Do not use dish soap, which strips your scalp.
The Verdict
Most guys should own one of two products. If your style is smooth and combed, buy Suavecito Original Hold. If it is textured, buy Baxter of California Clay Pomade. Add the TIGI wax or American Crew Fiber only if you wear your hair short and want visible, separated texture. For more on building a routine, see our best men's hair products guide.
More Grooming Guides
FAQs
The finish. Pomade gives shine and is built for smooth, slicked styles like side parts and pompadours. Clay dries matte and is built for texture and volume. Wax, and fibers like American Crew Fiber, sit in between: a pliable, mostly matte hold you can rework with your fingers for piece-y, separated texture.
A water-based pomade. Suavecito Original Hold, for example, washes out with water alone. Oil-based pomades are the hardest: Reuzel explains that ingredients like beeswax repel water, so rinsing does not work, and it recommends working conditioner into dry hair before shampooing.
Usually clay. A matte clay adds grip and makes hair look fuller, while a shiny pomade tends to clump fine hair together and show more scalp. Use a small amount and build up, because too much product of any kind weighs thin hair down.
Of our picks, Hanz de Fuko Claymation, which the brand rates as super high hold, and TIGI Matte Separation Workable Wax, which TIGI rates 5 out of 5 for hold and texture. Among pomades, Suavecito Original Hold and Layrite Original are both medium hold.
Neither, strictly. American Crew calls it a fiber and describes it as a high hold, low shine product with a pliable, matte finish, and recommends it for hair 1 to 3 inches long. In practice it behaves like a stiff wax or paste, which is why we group it with waxes here.